Skip to main content

The Archaeology of Fact-Checking: From “Chain Mail” to Information Warfare

| Julien Vandanjon-Rancoule | Press

For those of us who wore out the seats of our pants on wooden office chairs while waiting for a JPEG image to load line by line, misinformation has long had the feel of a craft. In 1981, we weren’t born with a smartphone in our hands, but with the promise of a Web that would be the “Great Leveler”—a space where knowledge would flow freely, without being naive about unsourced claims, but without real gatekeepers (See our introduction to this topic here). On one hand you may call it libertarian Far West but on another hand it was also a reminder that collective scrutiny and debate is a mandatory effort process of any said freedom of speech and democracy. Press satire drawings has long been a good example of that in modern world that grew significantly in audience along 20th century as the national propaganda efforts skyrocketed through world wars (hot or cold).

Wireless News Drawing from Military Greetings Postcards World War II by Watson / cit. Maryl Martin

At the turn of the 2000s, our first line of defense bore a name that still resonates like a digital Proustian madeleine: Hoaxbuster.  Back then, a “hoax” was a nuisance, a byproduct of mass culture that spread through endless email chains filled with recipients in the “CC” field—a nightmare for personal data privacy (GDPR) long before its time.

"Those were the heroic days.

...We went there to find out whether or not donating blood after eating strawberries would kill us, or whether Bill Gates was really going to share his fortune with everyone who forwarded his message."

Back then, fact-checking was a geek’s pastime. We felt a bit like Neo discovering bugs in the Matrix: all we had to do was lift the rug, find the original source, and the lie would vanish. There was a certain nobility to this hunt, a certainty that “the Truth” was a binary fact, a line of code that could be fixed. It was the era of technical innocence.


Then, the Web became “social.” And that's when everything changed.


Number of People using social media platforms 2004-2018 by ourworldindata.org

The Rise of Social Media 2004-2018 by OurWorldInData.org / source here


The shift to digital social media has transformed the small-scale craft of hoaxes into a systemic information war. We’ve seen fact-checking take on a new dimension and shift sides. It was no longer just passionate volunteers responding to rumors about the moon landings filmed in a studio by Stanley Kubrick.

Operation Lune, Mockumentary William Karel 2002 / source Arte France

Major players have entered the fray: AFP Factuel, Les Décodeurs at Le Monde, and RTBF, each with their own crisis response teams. Fact-checking has become institutionalized. It has evolved into a profession, with its own codes, charters (such as that of the IFCN), and, inevitably, its blind spots.


Is reality technically provable ?

What’s fascinating—and a bit melancholic for our generation—is seeing how a tool of liberation has become a tool of labeling. Fact-checking, once the weapon of the geeky counterculture against petty scams and urban legends, has at times become the enforcer of a certain official narrative. We’ve seen the emergence of “truth stamps” like the C2PA project, or the use of algorithms and editorial boards that no longer simply state “this photo is a fake,” but sometimes suggest “this opinion is dangerous.”

C2PA Initiative

As descendants of this pop culture that has taught us to be wary of monolithic narratives, this shift raises questions for us. We can’t help but view these new “priests of truth” with the same critical distance as we would an episode of The X-Files : we want to believe them, but we know that the government (or the ruling power structure, who may simply be the industry leaders, as suggested by technofeudal paradigm) )... so we intuitively suspect a truth bishop is always hiding a piece of the puzzle. Not falling into the slippery slope of conspiracy theories, one may still be able to challenge any transparency standard both as a tool for common intellectual hygiene and a potential for a selective whip in the hands of a few lobbyists. Here - sorry for the engineer jargon - the initiative try to answer the issue by sharing open-sourced technological response via worldwide code exchange Github network.

In the clickbait race for press survival, will medias endorse the non-profit effort of Joined Encrypted Metadata traceability in publications against shareholders, lobbies & commercial short-sighted interests ?

Behind it, a simple logic : "use certified cameras and compliant editing softwares that label frame-accurate or pixel-accurate what is real and what is artificial in any given image, sound sample or document". On paper, using complex contemporary encryption techniques and cloud based manifests in digital vaults, it's a response to the failure of DRM locking attemps from the 90s & 2Ks. 

Even if appealing, it quickly raises 2 sub-questions : 

1. Digital data (including hidden file metadata) had always been hackable in some way, maybe not instantly but at some point in time it becomes almost inevitable. Crypto token coding may seem safe for now but nobody knows if tomorrow evolved versions of current GPU processing capabilities or Quantic computing will be able to crack it open.

2. Even if press and professionally produced digital media CAN be proven original if needed, technically "original" still does not mean "true" as shooting conditions may still be staged, editing still creates - or removes - shifts in context and meaning (the already existing issues supporting the emergency of strenghtening media education worldwide).


CAN / DO People want to know ?

And last but not least, being able to prove something has been made in real life by a human does not mean this human is trustworthy, unbiased, nor today’s fast-paced, voracious consumer of short, LLM-summarized information will have access to interface buttons linking to source verification and fact-checking tools, as well as the patience—or simply the willingness and critical thinking skills—to question what they see or hear. Furthermore, there is no guarantee whatsoever that, without binding political will, digital media companies—including both the press and social media platforms—will comply with the implementation of costly systems that may at times harm their audience revenue.

The archaeology of fact-checking thus reveals this semantic shift: we have moved from correcting a bug (the factual error) to managing the narrative (the political interpretation). And it is precisely there—in this gap between the raw fact and its presentation—that the battle of 2026 is being fought, as we saw in the comments on the images of Renée Good’s killing by ICE state police in the United States.

The pinocchio fact checker test of Washington Post / on Youtube